Table of Contents Hide
Constitutional laws conform to a country’s constitution, while unconstitutional laws violate the principles and provisions outlined in the constitution.
TL;DR Constitutional Laws Vs. Unconstitutional Laws
The constitution serves as a legal foundation, outlining principles and balancing government powers. Constitutional laws implement these principles, while unconstitutional laws contradict them. Courts ensure laws comply with the constitution.
Constitutional laws adhere to a country’s constitution, while unconstitutional laws violate it.
What is the Constitution?
The Constitution is the bedrock of a nation’s legal system. It serves as a blueprint, outlining the fundamental principles and values that shape how a government operates. In simple terms, it defines the rules by which we all play.
The Constitution establishes the framework for balancing power between branches of government and enshrines individual rights and freedoms. It sets out the structure of governance, establishing an executive branch to enforce laws, a legislative branch to create laws, and a judicial branch to interpret them.
What are constitutional laws
Constitutional laws are laws that are in line with a country’s constitution. These laws are enacted to uphold and implement the principles, structure, and provisions outlined in the constitution. Constitutional laws set the framework for the functioning of the government, the protection of individual rights, and the distribution of powers among various branches of government.
What are Unconstitutional laws?
Unconstitutional laws are those that go against the principles and provisions laid out in a country’s constitution. These laws violate the fundamental rights and freedoms guaranteed to individuals by the constitution.
They can range from outright bans on certain activities or forms of expression to discriminatory policies that target specific groups.
How do Courts determine if a law is Unconstitutional?
Courts determine if a law is unconstitutional through a process known as judicial review. They assess the law’s compatibility with the constitution by:
Interpreting the Constitution: Courts analyze the language and intent of the constitution to understand its provisions and principles.
Examining the Law: The court reviews the challenged law to assess if it violates any constitutional rights or provisions.
Applying Legal Tests: Various legal tests, such as strict scrutiny or rational basis review, are used to evaluate the law’s constitutionality.
Precedents: Courts consider past rulings on similar issues to guide their decision-making.
Public Interest: Courts may consider the law’s impact on society and individual rights.
Oral Arguments: Attorneys present their arguments in court, defending or challenging the law’s constitutionality.
Issuing a Ruling: Based on their assessment, the court either upholds the law (constitutional) or declares it invalid (unconstitutional).
Courts, particularly the highest courts in a country, play a crucial role in safeguarding the constitution and ensuring that laws adhere to its principles.
Examples of Unconstitutional laws
One example of an unconstitutional law is the Sedition Act of 1798, which was passed by Congress during the presidency of John Adams.
This law made it a crime to criticize the government or its officials, and many individuals were arrested and jailed for expressing their dissenting views.
However, in the landmark case of New York Times Co. v. Sullivan in 1964, the Supreme Court ruled that laws prohibiting criticism of public officials are a violation of the First Amendment’s protection of free speech.
Another example is Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), where the Supreme Court upheld racial segregation under the doctrine “separate but equal.” This decision allowed for Jim Crow laws to be implemented across Southern states, enforcing racial discrimination and denying African Americans their constitutional rights.
Similarly, Roe v. Wade (1973) is another significant case involving an unconstitutional law. The Supreme Court ruled that state laws banning abortion violated a woman’s right to privacy as protected under the Fourteenth Amendment.
Featured Image By – jcomp on Freepik
Image 1 By – Freepik